Thursday, August 22, 2024

STRUCTURE ANALYSIS SHORT NOTES



INTRODUCTION

  • at the location of plastic hinge of a deformed str → Curvature = infinity

  • in a statically indeterminate structure, the formation of 1st plastic hinge will reduce the number of redundancies by one

  • Redundant structure → Completely closed ring, Fixed portal frame, Propped cantilever

  • Natural frequency of a mass m at the end of the cantilever beam → f=(1/2)3EI/ml3

  • Shail structure → Rigid curved surface, Built of sheets or plates 

Degree of freedom or independent displacement component

  • Pin-joint of plane frame = 2 (translation)

  • Pin-joint Space frame = 3 (translation)

  • Rigid-joint plane frame = 3 ( 1 rotation + 2 translation)

  • Rigid-joint Space frame = 6 (3 rotation + 3 translation)

Static indeterminacy

  • External determinacy (Dse) → Related to support condition

  • internal determinacy (Dsi) → Geometry of structure

  • Ds = Dse + Dsi

  • Dsi = n - 3

  • Plane Truss Ds = m + r - 2j = m - (2j - 3) 

  • Space Truss Ds = m + r - 3j 

  • Rigid-jointed Plane Frames Ds = 3m + r - 3j

  • Rigid-jointed Space Frames Ds = 6m + r - 6j


Planer S


Plane Truss 


Determinate 

Y = 3X

Ds = 0

m = 2j - 3

Perfect truss/frames

indeterminate 

Y > 3X

Ds > 0

m > 2j - 3

Redundant Truss/frame

Unstable 

Y < 3X

Ds < 0

m < 2j - 3

Deficiency Truss/frame

  • m + r >  2j  → this condition is Sufficient but not necessary Regarding  stability of truss

Stability

  • Reaction should be parallel, concurrent & 

  • External stability: neither concurrent, nor parallel & non-coplanar.

  • For stability: equilibrium equation should be satisfied concurrently at each & every joint of the structure.

  • For instability:  at least one joint of the str should be able to displace without causing change in length of at least one member

  • 2D = 3 reactⁿ & 3D = 6 reactⁿ

  • in a plane independent static equilibrium eqn = 03 ( Σ Fx, Σ Fy, Σ Mz)

  • Surface structure → Small thickness

Planer System

  • Partially constrained → Equilibrium eqn > No of force 

  • for indeterminate structure & essential unstable → No. of reactⁿ > Equilibrium equation

  • Reaction < 3 → essentially unstable

  • Y = Force & X = parts/members

Kinematic Indeterminacy

  • Pin-jointed plane frame → Dk = 2j - r

  • Pin-jointed space frame → Dk = 3j - r

  • Rigid-jointed space frame → Dk = 6j - r

  • J → number of joint, r → unknown reaction 

2D rigid frame/Beam

  • Dk = 3j - Re + Rr + m

  • Ds = 3m - 3j + Rr

Value of re (Unknown Reaction or Constraints)

  • Fix = 3

  • Free = 0

  • Hinged = 2 → free rotation support

  • Hinged with roller  = 1

  • Value of Rr = 3 - Re

METHOD OF ANALYSIS

  • A joint where several members meet, any applied moment will be distributed among the various members → in proportion to their stiffness

  • For equilibrium of deformable body we need a minimum 3 equilibrium equation  → Fx=Fy=M=0

  • indeterminate/Redundant Str → Equilibrium + Compatibility condition + Force-displacement relation require for analysis

  • Statically indeterminate/Redundant structure are always chosen over statically determinate structure

  • For a linear elastic structural analysis system minimization of potential energy → Yields compatibility condition 

Displacement/Equilibrium/Stiffness

Flexibility/Force/Compatibility

→ Displacements (∆, θ) are unknown & found by equilibrium equation

→ Kinematic indeterminacy

→ Dk < Ds

→ No of equilibrium condition method = Dk

→ Deflection based method

→ Not necessary to identify the redundant

DESSKM → SDM, MDM, KANI'S Method, Min potential energy method

→ BM & SF are unknown & found by additional compatibility condition

→ Static indeterminacy 

→ Ds < Dk

→ No of compatibility condition method = Ds = no of redundant force

→ Starts with equilibrium and compatibility state of internal force

→ Constant deformation method

Principal of Superposition

  • Hooke's law valid ( σ ∝ ε) i.e. material should behave Linear-elastic, effect of temp changes is considered, structure is analysed for the effect of support settlement 

  • Stress-strain relationship = linear

  • Small deformation

  • Resultant deflection due to all loads = Sum of individual deflection

  • Stiffness factor at joint = Sum of stiffness factors the member connected to the joint

FORCE METHOD

Betti's Law

  • P=Q

  • P12=P21

Maxwell's reciprocal theorem

  • it is a special case of Betti’s law

  • Validity → All structure with linear force displacement relation, any st obeying hooke's law

  • Use → Analysing indeterminate str, Can be applied to rotations caused by flexure, shear or torsion

  • pq=qp → Deflection at point P due to load at point Q =  deflection at Q due to load at point P

Unit load method (Virtual work method)

  • Apply unit load in the direction in which deflection is needed

  • Based on consistent deformation 

  • Virtual work → Work done by real forces due to hypothetical displacement or work done by hypothetical forces during real displacements 

  • =∫M.mdx /EI

  • M → due to external load, m →due to unit load

  • Force assumed & can’t omitted → Concentrated load on the mid span of a simply supported beam

  • Derived from the castigliano’s theorem

Strain energy method (Real work method)

  • U=UOA+UOB

Castigliano's Theorem

  • Strain energy method of finding out slopes and deflection

      1st theorem 

  • Principle of superposition is valid

  • Linearly or non-linear Elastic structure

  • dU/d=P, dU/d=M

     2nd theorem 

  • Any type of structure but linearly elastic

  • dU/dP=, dU/dM=

  • The first partial derivative of the total internal energy in a structure with respect to the force applied at any point is equal to the deflection at the point of application of that force in the direction of its line of action

Clapeyron's Three moment thᵐ

  • For continuous beam

  • Any type of cross section, No discontinuity such as hinges within the span, 

  • Eqn → Slope compatibility at that point

Column analogue method

  • Width of column = unity

  • Column dim = L x 1/EI → A = L/EI

  • Valid when Str has static indeterminacy up to 3

Flexibility matrix method

  • Unit force is applied at coordinate j & Displacement are calculated at all coordinate

  • δ12 → Displacement at 1 due to unit load at 2

  • jth Coordinate → A unit forces applied at co-ordinate J and the displacement are calculate at all coordinates 

  • Square symmetric matrix

  • Order of matrix(n x n) = Ds = Redundant force

  • Elements → Dependent on the choice of coordinate, Always dimensionally homogeneous

  • Each flexibility matrix element = displacement

  • Elementij=Elementji

  • Diagonal elements = Always (+ve), ≠ 0, ≠ (-ve)

  • Valid for stable structure

  • Flexibility matrix = 1/ Stiffness matrix

  • Flexibility = 1/stiffness = 1/K = ∆/P = θ/M

  • Note Stiffness matrix → Same property except order(n x n) = Dk

DISPLACEMENT METHOD

Stiffness Matrix Method

  • Analysis of indeterminate structure with lesser DS

  • Stiffness → Force require to produce unit displacement 

  • K = P/∆ = M/θ

  • for wall → K = ∞

  • Kij → force at i due to unit displacement at j

  • Order of matrix (n x n) = Dk

  • Size of basic stiffness matrix for plane truss member = 2x2

  • Stiffness matrix doubled → Deflection will be half

Slope Deflection Method (SDM)

  • G.A. Maney method

  • Axial & Shear deformation are neglected

  • Best → For Continuous Beam

  • Use of Kinematic redundant 

  • Number of simultaneous equation to be solved = Number of joints in the structure 

  • MAB=MFAB+(2EI/L)(2A+B)-6EI/l2

  • MBA=MFBA+(2EI/L)(2B+A)-6EI/l2

  • Deformation are considered to be caused by Bending moment only 

  • Joints are considered rigid → No change in value of angles between members 

Fixed End moment (Fix beam)

  • i. P at centre = PL/8

  • ii. Udl all span  = wL²/12, at centre = wL²/24 → Sagging, Point of contraflexure = L / 2√3 → from centre

  • iii. P eccentric = Pab²/L², Pa²b/L²

  • iv. ∆ settlement = 6EI∆/L²

  • v. M at centre = M/4

  • vi. UVL = wL²/20 (at w) & wL²/30 (at 0)

Moment Distribution method (MDM)

  • By prof. Hardy Cross 

  • Stable & Statically indeterminate structure

  • Best → For rigid frame

  • It is a Trial-error method, an iterative method

  • Use of Carry over factor and Distribution factor

Absolute Stiffness (K)

  • K = Flexural rigidity/Length = EI/L

  • Far end fix → K = 4EI/L

  • far end hinged → K = 3EI/L

  • Far end is a guided roller → K = EI/L

  • Far end is roller → 0

  • far end free → K = 0 

Distribution factor 

  • DF=Ki / Ki

  • DF=1  → All member meeting at a joint

  • Displacement factor → Δ = - 1.5 x DF

  • For end span, on the fixed end side → DF = 0

Relative stiffness

  • Far end is fixed → RS = I/L

  • Far end hinge → RS = 3I/4L

Carry Over Factor

  • COF = Carry over moment/Applied moment

  • Carry over moment → Moment developed at one end due to the applied moment at another end 

  • fix hinge or far end is fix = 1/2 → Propped cantilever

  • fix free or far end is Guided roller = -1 → = Cantilever

  • fix, hinge & hinged at mid span = a/b

  • Far end is simply supported or hinged = 0

Kani’s method

  • Successive approximation, Iterative approach for applying slope deflection method

  • Use of Rotational coefficient

  • If end of continuous beam is fixed → rotation contribution = 0

  • Used for → Fixed frame, Portal frame, Box frame

  • Any arithmetic error that creeps in will automatically get corrected 

  • An overhang can be conveniently dealt with by regarding it as a member with infinite length

Note

  • Maxwell’s diagram → Forces in bar members

  • Hinsburg’s method → Concept of substitute members

  • Newmark’s method → Deflection by numerical procedure

  • Williot-Mohr method → Displacement of joints in a Truss

TRUSS

  • Zero load test → To check the geometrical unstable

  • Stanchions → Compression members in truss

  • Primary unit of truss → Triangle

Properties of truss

  • Compressive parts are thicker than tensile parts

  • Truss transmits load → in axial direction → as Tension & Compression

  • Truss is said to be completely analysed when all member forces & their corresponding stress are determined.

  • Simplest geometrical form of truss is Triangle

  • Can't use Concrete as material for truss

Assumption in truss

  • Members are joined by Smooth pins or friction less pins

  • Self wt. of truss members is neglected

  • Truss str is loaded only at the joints

  • Members of a truss do not carry any flexural load

  • Note No assumption about all members have same cross-sectional area, Material Homogeneous isotropic elastic

Beam vs Truss

  • Beams can't transmit load in axial direction while trusses can

  • Beam is single member whereas truss is composed of many members

  • Beams, Frames → Flexural load → Shear & Bending

  • Truss → only Axial loads → Tension & Compression

Frame vs Truss

  • Trusses can't bend but frame can

  • BM is zero everywhere in the truss but frames have BM at the joints

Deflection/Displacement in truss

  • Angle wt method, Joint displacement method, Williot-Mohr method (Graphical method)

  • Deflection → Depends on Axial rigidity

  • Lack of fit → Causes both horizontal and vertical deflection

  • Total deflection → Force + Temp change + member too short or to long

  • Δ = nNL/AE + nLαΔT + ndL

  • N → Force due to external load , n → due to unit load

Force

  • F = P + kx

  • x=-(PkL/AE) / (k2L/AE)

Method of force analysis of truss/frame

  • 3 methods → Graphical, Method of joints, Method of sections

i. Graphical 

ii. Method of joints 

  • Unknown force < 3 → Not greater than 2

  • The members of the truss are connected together at their ends by friction pins.

iii. Method of sections

  • For easy solution use it 

Types of Truss

  • Forms of truss → Prott truss, Howe truss, warren truss and k-truss

i. Simple truss

  • A truss whose number of members is given by → m = 2j – 3

  • Consist entirely of a triangle, It can consists of any other shaped intermediate parts, as long as it is stable 

ii. Compound truss 

  • Formed by joining two or more simple trusses

  • Will be Rigid & determinant → if m = 3 + m1 + m2.

  • May be formed by connecting two simple rigid frames → by Three bars

King post truss

  • Stress carried by king post truss → Compressive stress

  • King post → Member used to prevent the sagging of beam and connected with the ridge

Hudson’s formula

  • Dead weight of the truss girder bridges → As a function of bottom chord area

  • W = 0.785 A

FRAME

  • Basic Perfect frame → Triangle

  • Appx analysis of building frames under vertical load → Point of inflection = 1/10 of span length from each end of the beam

  • Substitute method of Frame analysis → Frame is subjected to vertical dead load and live load

  • Malti-bay portal frame → SFintermediate column =SFend column

  • Point of inflection →  anywhere in the frame 

Moment resisting frame

  • A rigid frame detailed to provide good ductility and support for both lateral and gravity loads by flexure action

  • Classification → Ordinary, intermediate and Special MRF

Sway direction

  • No sway → Load & frame both are symmetric

  • Sway correction → Necessary when either the loading or the frame is unsymmetrical

  • Symmetric → Opp to load(P) from mid span or sway towards lesser load, Towards column of low stiffness, Towards hinged support

  • Unsymmetric → Side where ratio  (l/L) of column is less

  • Stiffness → Far end fix = 4EI/L, far end hinged = 3EI/L, far end free = 0 

ARCH

  • Arch subjected → SF, BM & Normal Thrust

  • Arch is a compression member

  • an arch subjected to pure compression due to a UDL → shall be a Parabolic Arch

  • In fixed arch structure → No hinges are necessary

  • An arch is used in long span bridges because → there is considerable reduction in Bending moment

Linear arch

  • Normal thrust only

  • LA Represents thrust line

Arch Components

  • Spanderal → Triangle space formed b/w the extrados and horizontal line draw through the crown of an arch

  • Skew back → An inclined surface or splayed surface on the abutment, from which the arch curve starts or ends

  • Haunch  → Lower half of arch b/w the crown and skew back

Note for both 2H-3H

  • Parabolic 3H or 2H Arch → if fully UDL loaded on whole span → BM = Radial shear = SF = 0, But normal thrust ≠ 0

  • 2H → ILD for Horizontal thrust = Parabolic (L/4h)

  • 3H → ILD for Horizontal thrust = Triangular (25L/128h)

  • Line of thrust in parabolic arch → Parabolic

  • Load system entirely vertical → Ha = Hb = H → Horizontal thrust is same at each support

3-HINGED ARCH

  • Hinged at supports and anywhere in rib (generally at crown)

  • 3H Arch → resist load by developing Thrust, radial shear & BM

  • Ds = 0 → Statically determinate

  • ΣFx = ΣFy = ΣMx = 0 

  • To find Reaction(Va, Vb)  → Use ΣM = 0 at other support

  • To find Horizontal thrust (H) → Use ΣM = 0 at crown

  • Radial Shear Sx=RAcos-Hsin

  • Normal shear Nx=RAsin+Hcos

  • Absolute Max hogging moment → When the point load is at crown

  • Max sagging (+ve) BM → 0.211 x L from support

  • Max hogging (-ve)  BM → 0.25 x L from support

3H Parabolic Arch

  • y=4hx(l-x)/l2

       Case-i Point load at crown

  • V = W/2

  • H = WL/4h

      Case-ii UDL 

  • Any Section → Subjected to normal thrust only

  • If Arch shape is Parabolic → Arch is Free from SF, BM

  • Va = Vb = wl/2

  • All over span H=wl2/8h

  • Half span H=wl2/16h

      Case-iii Supports not at same level (UDL)

  • H=wl2 / 2(h1 +h2)2

  • l1=(lh1 ) / (h1 +h2)

  • l2=(lh2 ) / (h1 +h2)

      Case-iv Supports not at same level (Point load at crown)

  •  H=Wl / (h1 +h2)2

3H Semicircular Arch

     Case-i Point load at crown

  • V = W/2

  • H = W/2

     Case-ii UDL over entire Span 

  • Va = Vb = wR

  • H = wR/2

  • BMx=R.x-wx2/2-H.y

  • BMx=(wR2/2)(sin2-sin)

  • BMMax=-wR2/8 → θ = 30°

  • BMc=0 =90°

Temp effect on 3H Arch

  • Due to temperature change → Stresses are not produced in the arch, but the horizontal thrust changes

  • Rise in temperature increases the length of the arc

  • Temp ↑es → H ↓es

  • New crown height → h=(h+l2/4h)T

  • Parabolic (UDL) → H ∝ 1/h → dH/H = - dh/h

2-HINGE ARCH

  • Ds = 1 → Statically indeterminate by one degree

  • Unknown force = 4 → Va, Vb, Ha, Hb

  • H=(Myds/EI) /(y2ds/EI)

2H Parabolic Arch

  • y=4hx(l-x)/l2

     Case-i UVL all over span

  • H = wl²/16h

     Case-ii UDL 

  • All over span → H = wl²/8h → Same as 3H

  • Half span → H = wl²/16h → Same as 3H

     Case-iii Point load (W)

  • At crown25Wl / 128h

  • Other than crown H=(5/8)(Wa(l-a)(al-a2+l2)/hl3)

2H Semicircular Arch

       Case-i UVL all over span

  • H = (2/3) x (wR/π)

      Case-ii UDL all over span

  • Va = Vb = wR

  • H = (4/3) x (wR/π)

  • Shear centre = 2R/π

      Case-iii UDL half of span either left or right side

  • H = (2/3) x (wR/π)

      Case-iv Point load (W)

  • At crown H=W/ → Does not depends on span or radii of arch

  • Other than crown H=(W/)sin2()

  • At crown → =90, At support → =0

Temp effect on 2H Arch

  • Temp ↑es → Horizontal thrust at support ↑es

  • Temp rise cause the max BM at the crown

  • Settle down → Horizontal thrust ↓es

  • H=(LT) /(y2ds/EI)

  • Parabolic H=15EIT/8h2 → H ∝ 1/h2

  • Semicircular H=4EIT/R2 → H ∝ 1/R2

Reaction locus of 2H arch

  • Semicircular arch  → Straight line or horizontal line → at πR/2 distance

  • Parabolic arch → Curved (Parabolic) → at 1.6h (end), 1.28h (mid) distance

Eddy's Theorem

  • Valid for Vertical loads only 

  • BMx ∝ Y

  • Y = Vertical intercept between the linear arch (or theoretical arch) and the centre line of the actual arch

  • In a 3H arch → The linear and the actual arch meet at least three points

JACK ARCH

  • Rise = 1/8 to 1/12 of the span

  • Joists are spaced 1 - 1.5 m

  • Composed of arches of either Bricks or lime, Concrete

CABLE & SUSPENSION BRIDGE 

  • Economical  span of bridge →  Cost of supporting system of one span = Cost of one pier

  • Flutter → unstable vibratory motion due to combined bending and torsion, in flexible plate like structure ex.suspension bridge deck, sign board

  • Bridges are classified as → Deck type

Cables

  • Cable & Wires → Tension members

  • Catenary Shape of cable due to self weight

  • Cable structure → Suspension bridge, cable stayed roof

  • Perfectly flexible cable → BM at every section = 0

  • Minimum TensionTmin=H → Where sag is max (at centre)

  • Max Tension Tmax=V2max+H2    → At Support

  • Dip or Sag = (1/10 to 1/15) of Horizontal span

Cable length (S)

  • S=0l1+(dy/dx)2

  • Support at same level S=l+8h2/3l

  • Support are not at same level S=l1+l2+2h12/3l1+2h22/3l22

Symmetrical cable subjected to UDL on horizontal span

  • Profile/Shape → Parabolic 

  • H=wl2/8h

  • y=(w/2H)x2

  • dy/dx=8hx/l2

  • T=H1+(dy/dx)2=H1+(8hx/l2)

  • Tmin=H=wl2/8h   x=0 (at max sag)

  • Tmax=(wl/2)1+(l/4h) x=l/2 (at support)

Suspension bridge

  • Suspension bridge with two hinged stiffening girder → Statically indeterminate of 1 degree

INFLUENCE LINE DIAGRAM

  • Influence line for a forcing function(SF,BM,reaction, axial force) gives its variation → at given section/point → for any postⁿ of point load

  • ILD for SF or BM → Linear or triangle → For any type of beam/str

  • Point load SF or BM at a point=Load x Ordinate of ILD of SF or BM

  • UDL SF or BM at a point=Load intensity  x Area of ILD of SF or BM

  • Ordinate of ILD → Always have dimension of Length

  • ILD for Stress function → Linear

  • The maximum ordinate of the ILD for BM at the fixed support in cantilever beam will occur at free end 

Muller-Breslau Principles

  • Use → determine Shape of ILD, Ordinate of ILD, Part of structure to be loaded to obtain the max effect

  • Applicable for both Determinate & indeterminate

  • Material is within elastic limit and obeys hooke's law

  • It is a straight application of Maxwell’s reciprocal theorem

  • Proof  → By principle of virtual work

Eff. of Rolling Load

  • Use above diagram for below condition → 1,2,3

1. Single Point Load

  • max SF : just left or right to that point

  • max BM : on the sectⁿ under the load

  • max -ve SF : right hand support

  • max +ve SF : left hand support

  • Absolute max BM : at centre or mid span

2. UDL < Span

  • Max BM → a/b = x / l -x → Ratio of span = ratio of load placed

  • max -ve SF → head of udl reaches at that point

  • max +ve SF → tail of udl reaches at that point

  • absolute max BM → CG of load at centre or mid span

  • absolute max -ve SF → Head at right hand support

  • absolute max +ve SF→ Tail at left hand support

3. UDL > Span  

  • Use dimag from above

Train of concentrated loads

  • Absolute max BM →  CG  at centre

  • Max BM at a point → The point load under consideration and the CG of train of point loads equidistant from the mid span 

  • Max -ve

ILD for deflection

  • Free end of cantilever → Cubic parabola with zero ordinate at fixed end and Max ordinate at free end


No comments:

Post a Comment

'Winners don't do different things. They do things differently' - Shiv Khera

Popular Posts